Challenge to New Pentagon Media Rules is a Sign of the Times
Published March 2026

Among the various threats, complaints and (likely unconstitutional) actions that the Trump administration has taken against the media, The New York Times reports that Defense Department officials are upset about a box on The Washington Post website soliciting tips about the military.
The box, labeled “Help us report on the Pentagon,” asked “Defense Department civilians and service members” to let the paper know of “changes within the Pentagon and throughout the U.S. military.”
The department’s lawyers repeatedly mentioned the solicitation during a court hearing in a case brought by The Times challenging new agency policies placed on journalists’ activities and coverage. This led many news organizations with long-time commitments to covering the Pentagon to relinquish their press passes rather than comply with the new rules. Most of these news organizations now cover Pentagon press briefings and events by obtaining daily press passes, rather than more permanent credentials.
While the new policy recognizes that the receipt of classified information by reporters is protected by the First Amendment—the legacy of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in the New York Times v. U.S. “Pentagon Papers” case and other court decisions—it adds that reporters who solicit such information could result in revocation of their press credentials and “consideration of whether [such a reporter] pose[s] a security risk.”
The First Amendment clearly protects much reporting activity. In a 1972 case, a plurality of U.S. Supreme Court justices observed (using a confusing double negative), “Nor is it suggested that news gathering does not qualify for First Amendment protection; without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the press could be eviscerated.” Yet in the same decision, the court wrote that, “It would be frivolous to assert … that the First Amendment, in the interest of securing news or otherwise, confers a license on either the reporter or his news sources to violate valid criminal laws.”
And in the case itself, Branzburg v. Hayes, the court held that the First Amendment does not excuse reporters from being called before grand juries to reveal confidential sources. This ruling has been mitigated by reporter’s shield protections that have been enacted whether by statute (in 40 states, including South Carolina, and the District of Columbia) or court decisions (nine states).
The point is that gathering news and information is often protected by the First Amendment, with some exceptions for actions such as trespassing on private property. The government can place some restrictions on access to physical spaces—so called “time, place and manner” restrictions as a result of practical or space considerations. It cannot limit access based on arbitrary or vindictive rationales.
A ruling is pending in the New York Times challenge to the Pentagon rules, but U.S. District Court Judge Paul Friedman seemed to express reservations about the policy during the hearing.
“A lot of things need to be held tightly and secure,” he said, “but openness and transparency allows members of the public to know what their government is doing.”
“Isn’t it more important than ever, now that we’re at war, that the public have information?,” Judge Friedman added. “This is what the First Amendment is all about.”
Update: Judge Will Review Seized Material
A federal magistrate judge will personally review the materials obtained in the FBI search of the home of Washington Post reporter Hannah Natanson on Jan. 14, as part of an investigation of a government contractor who allegedly kept classified government documents. The magistrate will provide any items related to the investigation to the government.
The Justice Department formerly had a policy that generally barred the government from seizing reporters’ records, but Attorney General Pam Bondi rescinded that policy last year. The raid may still have violated the federal Privacy Protection Act, which provides that such searches should be used only when there is no alternative way to collect needed evidence. Government lawyers failed to mention the Act when seeking the warrant for the search, which may be a violation of attorney ethics rules.
Eric P. Robinson is the Reid H. Montgomery Chair in Freedom of Information at the University of South Carolina’s School of Journalism and Mass Communications, where he teaches media and internet law as an associate professor at the USC School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and an academic affiliate of USC’s Joseph F. Rice School of Law. He is “of counsel” at Fenno Law in Charleston / Mount Pleasant. He has worked in media law for more than 30 years and is admitted to legal practice in New York and New Jersey and before the U.S. Supreme Court. This column is for educational purposes only; it does not constitute legal advice. Any opinions are his own, not necessarily those of his employers.
