Openness at Fourth Circuit, South Carolina Supreme Court

Published July 2025

Eric P. Robinson, USC School of Journalism and Mass Communications
By Eric P. Robinson, USC School of Journalism and Mass Communications

In late June the federal Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals—whose rulings are binding on federal trial courts in South Carolina—and the South Carolina Supreme Court both took actions independently to provide for some openness of proceedings that were previously closed or obscured from the press and public: immigration proceedings in the Fourth Circuit ruling and state judicial disciplinary proceedings in the South Carolina action.

The Fourth Circuit’s brief order, issued on June 26, granted a motion to remove restrictions on digital access to the online court file of a case brought by Georgetown University postdoctoral fellow Badar Khan Suri, who was detained for two months for allegedly spreading Hamas propaganda. He was released after a federal judge held that his detention violated the First and Fifth Amendments. Suri’s deportation has been stayed, and was affirmed by the appeals court.

The federal courts’ PACER system normally provides online access to all documents in federal criminal and civil court cases, including motions, briefs and court rulings. But many records for Suri’s case were not available, under a federal court rule that allows limiting the public’s remote electronic access only to “the docket maintained by the court” and “an opinion, order, judgment, or other disposition of the court” in a “proceeding relating to . . . immigration benefits or detention.” In other words, the entire case docket listing all the filings was available online, but only documents created and filed by the court itself were available. Other materials, including filings by Suri and the government, were only listed and could not be accessed online; they were available only in physical form, at the court clerk’s office in the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals courthouse annex in Richmond, Virginia.

The online news organization The Intercept, represented by attorneys with the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press (my one-time employer), intervened in the government’s deportation case against Suri and sought to make the case materials available electronically. The government did not object to the request, and the appeals court granted it.

This may seem a minor victory. But digital availability of materials in court cases—particularly deportation and other cases brought by the government—are important in monitoring court proceedings and keeping the government and the courts accountable to the public that they serve and to whom they answer.

Meanwhile, on June 25 the South Carolina Supreme Court issued a unanimous order requiring the bodies that oversee discipline of state court judges to begin releasing summaries of “lesser” judicial discipline cases—those with less severe penalties. This is more than what was previously disclosed about such cases.

Cases in which state judges are suspended, publicly reprimanded or removed from office were already disclosed. The new order will require quarterly disclosure of some information about judicial discipline cases that are dismissed or result in letters of caution, confidential admonitions or deferred discipline agreements.

The disclosure will summarize these cases but not identify judges by name. But the order requires that the summaries must include details such as the type of judge named in the complaint, a brief summary of the alleged or actual of judicial misconduct and the action taken. If the case is dismissed, the summary must state the basis for the dismissal. If some disciplinary action is taken, that must be specified.

Previously, the state courts’ Office of Judicial Counsel reported the numbers of such cases, along with the type of judge and the basic nature of the complaint. In the latest such report, the office reported receiving 558 complaints against judges from July 2023 through June 2024. This is close to triple the number of complaints received in 2019-2020. During this period, 492 cases were dismissed. Four cases resulted in a letter of caution, and three resulted in confidential admonitions. Two cases were closed because of deaths, and one was closed because of duplication or error. The Supreme Court issued an interim suspension of one judge, according to the report: St. George municipal judge David Lamar Little Jr. There were 199 unresolved complaints at the end of the reporting period.

The new disclosure comes after the South Carolina court system was criticized for its lack of transparency in judicial discipline (here and here).

While the disclosure is limited, it does give the public more insight into how and why the courts discipline judges. It will also hopefully give judges some idea of how to avoid getting in trouble in the first place.

Eric P. Robinson is the Reid H. Montgomery Chair in Freedom of Information at the University of South Carolina’s School of Journalism and Mass Communications, where he teaches media and internet law as an associate professor at the USC School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and an academic affiliate of USC’s Joseph F. Rice School of Law. He is “of counsel” at Fenno Law in Charleston / Mount Pleasant. He has worked in media law for more than 30 years and is admitted to legal practice in New York and New Jersey and before the U.S. Supreme Court. This column is for educational purposes only; it does not constitute legal advice. Any opinions are his own, not necessarily those of his employers.

Other recent columns